Valentine’s Day Dinner in the Hamptons: 3 Romantic Options

Home » Valentine’s Day Dinner in the Hamptons: 3 Romantic Options

Valentine’s Day Dinner in the Hamptons: 3 Romantic Options

With Valentine’s Day quickly approaching, now is the time to secure a table before the best restaurants are fully booked. If you’re looking for a romantic spot to enjoy an intimate dinner with your partner, the Hamptons offers several excellent options. Below, you’ll find three great restaurants that we recommend for Valentine’s Day dinner in the Hamptons – but these are just a starting point. Throughout the Hamptons (and Long Island), there is no shortage of world-class establishments offering nearly every cuisine imaginable.

As you compare your options, remember that the type of food offered is only one of several important considerations. For Valentine’s Day especially, you want to be sure the restaurant offers the right ambiance, location and reputation. Here are three romantic options to consider:

Calissa

1020 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill

Opened in 2017, Calissa has become a top destination for couples seeking a romantic Valentine’s Dinner in the Hamptons. The restaurant serves modern Mediterranean dishes based on “classic recipes from the Aegean Islands made with exceptional ingredients, such as local and wild crudo, seasonal salads, and mezze.”
The ambiance is upscale without being overly formal. (The dining style can be described as “casual elegant.”) For this Valentine’s Day, Calissa is offering several special additions to its classic menu, including red snapper and osso buco. Chocolate-covered strawberries, chocolate fondue and champagne pairings will also be available. Get more information

Nick & Toni’s

136 N Main St, East Hampton

Nick & Toni’s has been an East Hampton fixture since the 1980s, yet its dishes and atmosphere are as fresh and fashionable as ever. The famed restaurant offers Italian-Mediterranean cuisine in a “Tuscan farmhouse setting.” It has been prominently featured in numerous publications, including the New York Times, Forbes and Hamptons Magazine, just to name a few.
Celebrity spottings are common at Nick & Toni’s, but that doesn’t mean you have to be red-carpet royalty to secure a table. The atmosphere is warm and inviting – high-end, but not stuffy. For this Valentine’s Day, the restaurant is offering a 4-course prix-fixe menu with options like oven-roasted halibut, pan-seared foie gras and chocolate tarts for dessert. For those who can’t make it on Valentine’s Day proper, the restaurant is also inviting guests to “celebrate your love ALL weekend long” with a la carte dining and specials running from Friday, Feb. 16 to Sunday, Feb. 18. Get more information

Scarpetta Beach (Gurney’s)

290 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk

Spend a romantic evening on the East End with a delicious dinner at this upscale Italian restaurant in Montauk. Scarpetta Beach, named after the iconic sister restaurant in Manhattan, is actually one of several seaside eateries located within Gurney’s Resort & Seawater Spa.This gives you multiple dining experiences to choose from, including intimate heated igloos overlooking the ocean (although those typically sell out early).

At Scarpetta Beach, the atmosphere is fresh and sophisticated with a midcentury-modern aesthetic, infused with coastal themes. It’s perfect for a romantic Valentine’s dinner, and the restaurant is offering an exquisite prix-fixe menu to make the night special. For the main course, you’ll choose between prime sirloin or cavatelli. Other highlights include seared scallops, chilled pea soup with crab and cinnamon panna cotta for dessert. For the ultimate Valentine’s Day experience, book an overnight stay at the resort to enjoy the relaxing spa, live music, special cocktail hours and everything else the village of Montauk has to offer. Get more information

Make your night even more relaxed. Leave the driving to us!

Make your night even more relaxed. Leave the driving to us! The best, safest and most comfortable way to travel on Valentine’s Day is to use an experienced Hamptons limousine service like Jackrabbit Limo. Our professional chauffeurs can escort you to any restaurant in the Hamptons, as well as other destinations throughout Long Island and NYC. Choose from gorgeous luxury sedans, limos and other vehicles to make your travel relaxed, easy and stress-free. We’ll do the driving, so you don’t have to worry about traffic, directions or parking ruining your romantic evening.

Our professional chauffeurs can escort you to any restaurant in the Hamptons, as well as other destinations throughout Long Island and NYC. Choose from gorgeous luxury sedans, limos and other vehicles to make your travel relaxed, easy and stress-free. We’ll do the driving, so you don’t have to worry about traffic, directions or parking ruining your romantic evening.

Reserve your car online, request a quote, or call us at (631) 600-7700 for more information.

Valentine’s Day Dinner in the Hamptons: 3 Romantic Options